Shamshad Begum Or Noorjahan Options

[sbfan]

Hi friends

Here I present a song from Khandaan- Nj movie 1941
This song

"MERI AMMI KA RAJ BHALA " is credited to noorjahan but on listening i am doubtful that it is by shamshad . other sources on net say we have only one song duet " chalo paniya bharan " by shamshad ,noorjahan(which is already u/l). Can anyone clear ,my doubt . It is an old recorded listen with high voulme.

regards

Ashish

[pradeepasrani]

Meri Ammi Ka Raaj Bhala is Noorjehan in my view and if my memory serves me right, she sings in the movie too. Pee Le Pee Le Oh Morey Raja, on the other hand is Shamshad. I am not sure if it was retained in the movie but if that's the case, then it is likely to be picturised on the lady who seduces Pran, the hero of the movie.

Pradeep

[sbfan]

Meri Ammi Ka Raaj Bhala is Noorjehan in my view and if my memory serves me right, she sings in the movie too. Pee Le Pee Le Oh Morey Raja, on the other hand is Shamshad. I am not sure if it was retained in the movie but if that's the case, then it is likely to be picturised on the lady who seduces Pran, the hero of the movie.

Pradeep

Hi Pradeep ji

Actually when i listened i found some maturity in the voice and more nasal content than noorjahan used ."Shamshad is elder than noorjahan and she sounds mature than noorjahan "therefore i thought ot may be shamshad version. i have not seen the movie.i guess from the song that it must be picturised on a child who ultimately grew to noorjahan .therefore it may be possible that on child it was picturised and by shamshad. i am guessing it as i am not familiar with the story.
waiting for reply

with warm regards

ashish