QUOTE(parag_sankla @ Oct 12 2009, 11:45 PM)
Venkat ji, here are my 2 cents about the "similarity of voices between Meena ji and Geeta ji". These are purely my personal views with a strict IMHO (In my humble opinion) written all over it:
I feel that Geeta ji's voice was very expressive one and had a "third dimension" to it. Apart from the length and the breadth, it had a width. Hers was not a sweet sugar like plain straight voice, but had a "firak" , a special lilt, a light swing so gentle, yet so pleasing. Listen to the non-film song "Haule haule hawa dole". In the opening lines she sings it "Haule haule..haayein.. dole". The word "haayein" has that special swing effect.
About the expressiveness, I always keep thinking about these 3 songs from the film Toofan Aur Diya (1956). Its not a Guru Dutt film and does not have music by either S D Burman (Geeta ji's mentor), or O P Nayyar or Hemant Kumar. Its Vasant Desai for whom she has sung relatively less songs. All the 3 songs are for a child artist played by Satish Vyas.
1) Meri chhoti si behen (duet with Lata ji) : With all the due respect to Lata ji, the most popular female playback singer of HFM, this song clearly shows what Geeta ji could do when pitted against Lata ji. The "chulbulaapan" in her voice is unmatched.
2) Phal ki bahaar hai : A simple song for a fruit vendor turns out such a rhythmic and enjoyable one! Listen to the way she sings "khat pat khat pat" and "ohh ho ho..lutadi hai humne foolwaari"
3) Meri aan bhagwaan : A perfect song for the situation, great lyrics and great singing with passion. Geeta ji demonstrates she can go to higher scales if the song demands it and still be expressive!
Regards
Parag
No doubt, in that 'Haule Haule Hawa Dole" song, the starting line along with the accompanying electric guitar clip is very special. It takes you into a world of "solitude, loneliness, tanhaayi"!!
Sure enough, during my childhood, Vividhbharati used to broadcast this song mostly in the afternoon when our residential area in Hyderabad used to be pin-drop silent!! That is how I cherish and remember this great song till date!!
And yes, I think Mahesh and Aditya are right in that Geeta Dutt was not given her due, to the extent that even Suman Kalyanpur got a higher profile than Geeta! All in all, tragedies chased Geeta Dutt all through her life. Not only an unfaithful and indifferent husband, but even a disloyal and fair-weather Music Director!!!
How sad it was that Geeta was ringing up OPN around 1959/60 and pleading with him for songs, by which time OPN was firmly in the grip of Asha Bhosle!! Geeta Dutt was a great singer, but unfortunately was no match to the famous sisters in the ways of the world!! But, despite all the odds, she has achieved quite a lot in HFM and left an indelible mark.
Open to correction!!
Venkat