The Three Reigning Queens, Albums of Madhubala, Meena Kumari & Nargis Options

[parag_sankla]

Another wonderful presentation with "from the bottom of the heart" write-up. Here are 2 cents from my side:

Most likely the song "Chali radhe raani" sung by Geeta ji was a version song. The other song sung by her, the divine beauty ("Chaand hain wohi") was in the film in the first few weeks of its release. Later on it was deleted from the film. Now we can only imagine how Bimalda would have filmed this song on Meena Kumari.

In case this information is incorrect and any one has the video of any of the above two songs of Geeta ji, please post the same.

Thanks and Best Regards
Parag

Parag, your 2 cents is always like a treasure cove tucked away into memory cavern. Thanks. Cheers. -S

Another special reason why the song "Chaand hain wohi" is a personal favorite of mine and close to my heart is that in this song Geeta ji sings my name:

Raag hain wohi, Parag hain wohi pawan
phir bhi kyun udaas hain, udaas mera mann



Regards
Parag

[swarapriya]

Swarapriya

Arun Kumar Mukherjee is primarily known as the playback voice for Ashok Kumar, although his playback starred a few years before the famous Dheere Dheere Aa Re of Qismat (1943). He obviously understood orchestration which led to a handful of music direction assignments upto the mid-50s.

Geeta's Chali Radhe Rani is definitely a version song.

Asit Baran was a very good and respected singer of the 40s who sang some great songs for Pankaj Mullick and RC Bhoral under the New Theatres banner in 43-45. Toota Hai Naata is not wholly original and seems inspired by Roshan's big hit from Malhar sung by Mukesh - Dil Tujhe Diya Tha Rakhne Ko.

Thank you Faraaj for sharing all this information. Cheers. -S

[nandi]

Thanks for this marvelous collection and more so for the interest it generated
nandi

[swarapriya]

Thanks for this marvelous collection and more so for the interest it generated
nandi

You're very welcome, Nandi. Cheers. -S

[swarapriya]

(Nargis) Pyaar (1950)

Here is a beautiful early album from Burmanda. It has several great songs. Burmanda uses only three singers here for 10 songs; Geeta, Shamshad, and Kishore. Incidentally, this is the only movie in which Kishoreda lip synched for Raj Kapoor.

There are several good songs here. I love the way Geetaji sang "Aa Gayi Re". The way she streches the word "Gayi" as "Gayiiiiii ..." is absolutely heart stealing. When a song needed a "lift" or "oomph", I don't believe anyone even comes close to Geetaji. Also I love the way she starts and ends the song with humming "Bum Bum ...". Just love it. Unfortunately, qaulity of this song is a notch below average.

There are some more songs with so so average quality. "Jalti Hai Duniya-1" and "Mohabbat Ka Chhota" are these songs. Rest of the songs have pretty good quality. These songs came from various sources including the Forum members. Thank you.

Now for the songs ...

This post has been edited by swarapriya: Jan 17 2010, 10:38 AM

[Exon]

(Meena) Parineeta (1953)

I am not familiar with the work of the music director of this movie, Aroon Kumar Mukherjee. Besides this film, it appears like he gave music to “Pratima (1945)”, “Muqaddar (1950)”, “Samaaj (1954)”, and “Teen Bhai (1955)”. He seems to have sang in some movies too. “Kismat” made in 1943 was one of them. Too bad he didn’t get opportunities to provide music for more films because he proved his prowess by composing some beautiful songs for this movie. My favorite one is by Geetaji that seems to make a definitive statement. The song “Chaand Hai Wohi” is rendered with such sweetness and sung as if Geetaji put her whole soul into it. This beautiful composition is brilliant, intense, and romantic all at the same time. The listening experience of this mellifluous song leaves you totally consumed. Mannada’s both versions of the song “Chali Raadhe Rani” offer soul stirring experiences as well. Asha also has a couple of beautiful solos. Especially her song “Gore Gore Haathon Mein” is very enchanting to listen to. The song is made special the way the antaraas return to the mukhdaas in the composition with percussion instruments giving able support. Let me also mention about the song by Ashit Baran, who also starred in the movie as the “other” person in Meena Kumari’s life. His song “Toota Hai Naata” almost sounds like Hemantda’s, yet it has distinctiveness of its own. Bimalda seamlessly integrates these songs in such a way that they become part of the narrative, smooth and beautiful, but never obtrusive.

Now for the beautiful songs from this film ...

Swarapriya

Arun Kumar Mukherjee is primarily known as the playback voice for Ashok Kumar, although his playback starred a few years before the famous Dheere Dheere Aa Re of Qismat (1943). He obviously understood orchestration which led to a handful of music direction assignments upto the mid-50s.

Geeta's Chali Radhe Rani is definitely a version song.

Asit Baran was a very good and respected singer of the 40s who sang some great songs for Pankaj Mullick and RC Bhoral under the New Theatres banner in 43-45. Toota Hai Naata is not wholly original and seems inspired by Roshan's big hit from Malhar sung by Mukesh - Dil Tujhe Diya Tha Rakhne Ko.

I believe there is one more version song by Geeta Dutt, 'chali dulhaniya'; I only have Asha's version.

There is one more Asha song in this album, 'pehale tum yaad aa rahe'. The audio with me is quite noisy.

Exon

[Exon]

(Nargis) Pyaar (1950)

Here is a beautiful early album from Burmanda. It has several great songs. Burmanda uses only three singers here for 10 songs; Geeta, Shamshad, and Kishore. Incidentally, this is the only movie in which Kishoreda lip synched for Raj Kapoor.

There are several good songs here. I love the way Geetaji sang "Aa Gayi Re". The way she streches the word "Gayi" as "Gayiiiiii ..." is absolutely heart stealing. When a song needed a "lift" or "oomph", I don't believe anyone even comes close to Geetaji. Also I love the way she starts and ends the song with humming "Bum Bum ...". Just love it. Unfortunately, qaulity of this song is a notch below average.

There are some more songs with so so average quality. "Jalti Hai Duniya-1" and "Mohabbat Ka Chhota" are these songs. Rest of the songs have pretty good quality. These songs came from various sources including the Forum members. Thank you. Also, it seems like I am missing a song by Geetaji. Details are shown in red italics in the table below. If anyone of you have it, please kindly share. Thanks.

Now for the songs ...

SP,

I think, you have uploaded all songs in this album, with no songs missing. 'Chup chup' are starting words for 'aagayi re' song.

Exon

[swarapriya]

I believe there is one more version song by Geeta Dutt, 'chali dulhaniya'; I only have Asha's version.

There is one more Asha song in this album, 'pehale tum yaad aa rahe'. The audio with me is quite noisy.

Exon

Thanks Exon. Why don't you go ahead and upload them. Someone may still like to hear these songs anyway. Cheers. -S

[Exon]

I believe there is one more version song by Geeta Dutt, 'chali dulhaniya'; I only have Asha's version.

There is one more Asha song in this album, 'pehale tum yaad aa rahe'. The audio with me is quite noisy.

Exon

Thanks Exon. Why don't you go ahead and upload them. Someone may still like to hear these songs anyway. Cheers. -S

Parineeta (1953)

Asha Bhosle:
tum yaad aa rahe, kaun mere dil ko (3:14 \ 128)

The song audio originated from HF member.

Exon

[swarapriya]

Thanks for sharing the song, Exon. Cheers. -S

[swarapriya]

(Madhubala) Saqi (1952)

Here is a nice album from C. Ramchandra. Apart from all the songs from this album, I am uploading a whole bunch of music clips from this album in the second posting. Here are the songs in the first posting ...

This post has been edited by swarapriya: Jan 19 2010, 06:07 AM

[swarapriya]

Music Clips From "Saqi (1952)"

Here are several music clips from this album, all thanks to the Forum members ...

This post has been edited by swarapriya: Jan 19 2010, 06:16 AM

[swarapriya]

(Meena) Baadbaan (1954)

I am uploading four songs from this album. The quality of these songs is so so. Three missing songs are shownin in red italics in the table below. Please kindly share these if you have them. I am also uploading Lata's version song of "Kaise Koi"". This is from her album Lata's Shraddhanjaali-2".

Here are the songs ...

This post has been edited by swarapriya: Jan 24 2010, 10:47 PM

[romesh]

(Meena) Baadbaan (1954)

I am uploading four songs from this album. The quality of these songs is so so. Three missing songs are shownin in red italics in the table below. Please kindly share these if you have them. I am also uploading Lata's version song of "Kaise Koi"". This is from her album Lata's Shraddhanjaali-2".

Here are the songs ...

dear SP

here are two missing songs

1-jai deva ho humpe rakho----160kbps--2.59mts
2--jati hai jati aaj naiya mori--192kbps--2.52mts

romesh

[romesh]

(Meena) Baadbaan (1954)

I am uploading four songs from this album. The quality of these songs is so so. Three missing songs are shownin in red italics in the table below. Please kindly share these if you have them. I am also uploading Lata's version song of "Kaise Koi"". This is from her album Lata's Shraddhanjaali-2".

Here are the songs ...

dear SP

here are two missing songs

jai deva ho humpe--160kbps--2.59mts
2--jati hai jati hai aaj naiya mori--192kbps--2.52mts

romesh