Twin Songs Options

[Hari Ram]

Film: Pyar Ka Sagar (1961)
Music: Ravi
Lyrics: Prem Dhawan
Singer: Mukesh

Song 1: sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale (BitRate: 128; 4:36min)

Song 2: ho gaye do roz mein ... vafaa jinse ki bevafaa ho gaye (BitRate: 128; 3:15min)

i downloaded sadaa khush rahe tu...thinking it has something that my version doesnt have....as the time shown was over a minute longer than my 3 min version..................but...alas...the time given here is incorrect.......n this version too is of 3:16 .........i keep bemoaning my ratio...with all my idiotic downloads

Behenji.t.m,

Sorry for the error. Now, I have corrected the duration.
I don't know if there is any longer version of the song.
For my mistake, you get 2 songs from me; PM your request.

Hari Ram

[Talaikya]

Film: Pyar Ka Sagar (1961)
Music: Ravi
Lyrics: Prem Dhawan
Singer: Mukesh

Song 1: sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale (BitRate: 128; 4:36min)

Song 2: ho gaye do roz mein ... vafaa jinse ki bevafaa ho gaye (BitRate: 128; 3:15min)

Hari Ram ji. I believe these are two different songs. Neverthe less both are great songs and thanks for
u/l but may be wrong thread.

Desai bhai,

I chose these songs as twin, based on their tune.

Hari Ram

I can't see them as twins either Hari Ram ji. Just my 2 cents... not disputing your ear or anything

is there a longer version of sadaa khush rahe?

I listened to two separate tracks I have, and both are much the same - 3.15 or thereabouts. I guess if someone has a Video/ DVD they can check for a longer version.

[Hari Ram]

Film: Pyar Ka Sagar (1961)
Music: Ravi
Lyrics: Prem Dhawan
Singer: Mukesh

Song 1: sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale (BitRate: 128; 4:36min)

Song 2: ho gaye do roz mein ... vafaa jinse ki bevafaa ho gaye (BitRate: 128; 3:15min)

Hari Ram ji. I believe these are two different songs. Neverthe less both are great songs and thanks for
u/l but may be wrong thread.

Desai bhai,

I chose these songs as twin, based on their tune.

Hari Ram

I can't see them as twins either Hari Ram ji. Just my 2 cents... not disputing your ear or anything

Talaikya,

I don't know why I hear striking similarity between the two song tunes. Try to skip the second song's mukhda and listen to the antara. Compare the lines 'sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale' and 'vafaa jinse ki, bevafaa ho gaye'. If I am the only one seeing the smilarity, I will remove this set from the list.

Hari Ram (no 'ji' please)

[lakshmi]

Film: Pyar Ka Sagar (1961)
Music: Ravi
Lyrics: Prem Dhawan
Singer: Mukesh

Song 1: sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale (BitRate: 128; 4:36min)

Song 2: ho gaye do roz mein ... vafaa jinse ki bevafaa ho gaye (BitRate: 128; 3:15min)

Hari Ram ji. I believe these are two different songs. Neverthe less both are great songs and thanks for
u/l but may be wrong thread.

Desai bhai,

I chose these songs as twin, based on their tune.

Hari Ram

I can't see them as twins either Hari Ram ji. Just my 2 cents... not disputing your ear or anything

Talaikya,

I don't know why I hear striking similarity between the two song tunes. Try to skip the second song's mukhda and listen to the antara. Compare the lines 'sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale' and 'vafaa jinse ki, bevafaa ho gaye'. If I am the only one seeing the smilarity, I will remove this set from the list.

Hari Ram (no 'ji' please)

I think Hari Ram is right. I played the songs to my son who knows nothing about Indian songs. He said the tunes are the same. This is one of the criteria for twin songs. Hari Ram, there is no need to delete the songs.

Lakshmi

[Hari Ram]

Talaikya,

I don't know why I hear striking similarity between the two song tunes. Try to skip the second song's mukhda and listen to the antara. Compare the lines 'sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale' and 'vafaa jinse ki, bevafaa ho gaye'. If I am the only one seeing the smilarity, I will remove this set from the list.

Hari Ram (no 'ji' please)

I think Hari Ram is right. I played the songs to my son who knows nothing about Indian songs. He said the tunes are the same. This is one of the criteria for twin songs. Hari Ram, there is no need to delete the songs.

Lakshmi

Lakshmi,

Thanks for checking on the song. That was a clever way to check the tune.
How come your son didn't get your 'hindi music' gene?

Hari Ram

[lakshmi]

Talaikya,

I don't know why I hear striking similarity between the two song tunes. Try to skip the second song's mukhda and listen to the antara. Compare the lines 'sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale' and 'vafaa jinse ki, bevafaa ho gaye'. If I am the only one seeing the smilarity, I will remove this set from the list.

Hari Ram (no 'ji' please)

I think Hari Ram is right. I played the songs to my son who knows nothing about Indian songs. He said the tunes are the same. This is one of the criteria for twin songs. Hari Ram, there is no need to delete the songs.

Lakshmi

Lakshmi,

Thanks for checking on the song. That was a clever way to check the tune.
How come your son didn't get your 'hindi music' gene?

Hari Ram

No problem. My son has a pretty good ear to the music. Unfortunately, he was not exposed to indian film music. I also listened to the 2 songs. The tunes are the same except for the first few lines(mukhda).

[venkat]

Talaikya,

I don't know why I hear striking similarity between the two song tunes. Try to skip the second song's mukhda and listen to the antara. Compare the lines 'sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale' and 'vafaa jinse ki, bevafaa ho gaye'. If I am the only one seeing the smilarity, I will remove this set from the list.

Hari Ram (no 'ji' please)

I think Hari Ram is right. I played the songs to my son who knows nothing about Indian songs. He said the tunes are the same. This is one of the criteria for twin songs. Hari Ram, there is no need to delete the songs.

Lakshmi

Lakshmi,

Thanks for checking on the song. That was a clever way to check the tune.
How come your son didn't get your 'hindi music' gene?

Hari Ram

No problem. My son has a pretty good ear to the music. Unfortunately, he was not exposed to indian film music. I also listened to the 2 songs. The tunes are the same except for the first few lines(mukhda).

Bravo, Lakshmi and Hari Ram. You two are among the newer jewels adornig the HF crown!

[Hari Ram]

Bravo, Lakshmi and Hari Ram. You two are among the newer jewels adornig the HF crown!

Nothing of that sort, Venkat.
I enjoy participating, reading many music related posts and listening to some rare songs contributed by members of this forum.
In return, with my spare time, I try to share what ever little collection I have got.

Hari Ram

[Anupama]

Film: Pyar Ka Sagar (1961)
Music: Ravi
Lyrics: Prem Dhawan
Singer: Mukesh

Song 1: sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale (BitRate: 128; 4:36min)

Song 2: ho gaye do roz mein ... vafaa jinse ki bevafaa ho gaye (BitRate: 128; 3:15min)

Hari Ram ji. I believe these are two different songs. Neverthe less both are great songs and thanks for
u/l but may be wrong thread.

Desai bhai,

I chose these songs as twin, based on their tune.

Hari Ram

I can't see them as twins either Hari Ram ji. Just my 2 cents... not disputing your ear or anything

is there a longer version of sadaa khush rahe?

I listened to two separate tracks I have, and both are much the same - 3.15 or thereabouts. I guess if someone has a Video/ DVD they can check for a longer version.

Great thread!
I have this DVD (Pyaar Ka Saagar). Lemme check - will get back!

[mohanflora]

Venkat Ji, Thanks for letting me know of this version of the song.

Yeh Mera Prem Patra
1:40 Mins, 160 Kbps.

Shish bhai,

Thanks for uploading this trio from Sangam. I remember this sad version in the movie. However, I don't recollect the duet version; gives me a reason to watch the movie after a long time.
Wasn't this song that caused rift between S and J?

Hari Ram

Hari Bhai,

Unfortunately, the Big Sisters of HFM (one or the other or both) were responsible for many a rift and much bad-blood in Hindi Film Music field! Not only for the SJ rift.

But, that would need a full-fledged thread to understand!

Venkat

Venkat,
Thanks for your message!
I am trying to find your "rifts" thread.Where is it posted!

mohanflora

[venkat]

Venkat Ji, Thanks for letting me know of this version of the song.

Yeh Mera Prem Patra
1:40 Mins, 160 Kbps.

Shish bhai,

Thanks for uploading this trio from Sangam. I remember this sad version in the movie. However, I don't recollect the duet version; gives me a reason to watch the movie after a long time.
Wasn't this song that caused rift between S and J?

Hari Ram

Hari Bhai,

Unfortunately, the Big Sisters of HFM (one or the other or both) were responsible for many a rift and much bad-blood in Hindi Film Music field! Not only for the SJ rift.

But, that would need a full-fledged thread to understand!

Venkat

Venkat,
Thanks for your message!
I am trying to find your "rifts" thread.Where is it posted!

mohanflora

It's right on top now.

[shish]

Movie Name : Taj Mahal (1963)
Singer : Lata Mangeshkar, Mohd Rafi
Music Director : Roshan
Lyrics : Sahir Ludhianvi

Jo Wada Kiya Woh I
3:15 Mins, 160 Kbps


Jo Wada Kiya Woh II
2:37 Mins, 160 Kbps


Jo Wada Kiya Woh III
1:49 Mins, 160 Kbps


The version II and Version III are recorded from streaming Video. The quality is ok ok.

Shishma.

[shish]

Movie Name : Dil Hai Ke Manta Nahi
Music Director : Nadeem-Shravan
Lyrics : Faiz Anwar


Dil Hai Ke Manta Nahin I
Singers : Anuradha Paudwal, Kumar Sanu
6:12 Mins, 128 Kbps



Dil Hai Ke Manta Nahin II
Singer : Anuradha Paudwal
6:12 Mins, 128 Kbps

[Anupama]

Film: Pyar Ka Sagar (1961)
Music: Ravi
Lyrics: Prem Dhawan
Singer: Mukesh

Song 1: sadaa kush rahe tu jafaa karne waale (BitRate: 128; 4:36min)

Song 2: ho gaye do roz mein ... vafaa jinse ki bevafaa ho gaye (BitRate: 128; 3:15min)

Hari Ram ji. I believe these are two different songs. Neverthe less both are great songs and thanks for
u/l but may be wrong thread.

Desai bhai,

I chose these songs as twin, based on their tune.

Hari Ram

I can't see them as twins either Hari Ram ji. Just my 2 cents... not disputing your ear or anything

is there a longer version of sadaa khush rahe?

I listened to two separate tracks I have, and both are much the same - 3.15 or thereabouts. I guess if someone has a Video/ DVD they can check for a longer version.

Great thread!
I have this DVD (Pyaar Ka Saagar). Lemme check - will get back!

I've checked the DVD and there is not much difference..... just a bit here and there. If anybody still needs it, I'll be sure to upload it.

[behenji.turned.mod]

thx a lot for ur effort anupama...but if u say there isnt much difference..

was very sweet of u to look into that for us