From Here And There Options

[cinemaniac2]

I think this song(if u call it a song) is not listed- or uploaded here

KK is reciting without any music accompaniment- just like the verses of Rafi in Pyaasa.

very nice.

guess the movie

[cinemaniac2]

CM2,

Can you reconcile your upload above with the following upload from "Dilli Ka Thug" by BJ in his thread "Pakka Dhaaga".

http://www.hamaraforums.com/index.php?show...indpost&p=80934

Upon listening, they seem to be the same song.

If you notice the starting chal re ameeran in both the songs is quite different- after O bandariya the song sounds the same- but again in the end it is little bit different.

Both songs had Ravi as the music director.

mine is surely from Bombay Ka chor.

Maybe SB could shed some light.

[hits]

CM2,

Can you reconcile your upload above with the following upload from "Dilli Ka Thug" by BJ in his thread "Pakka Dhaaga".

http://www.hamaraforums.com/index.php?show...indpost&p=80934

Upon listening, they seem to be the same song.

If you notice the starting chal re ameeran in both the songs is quite different- after O bandariya the song sounds the same- but again in the end it is little bit different.

Both songs had Ravi as the music director.

mine is surely from Bombay Ka chor.

Maybe SB could shed some light.

What's interesting is that the lyricists of these songs are different. Now remember that "Chal ri amiran...chal re fakire" is a general expression used in some other dialougues/songs too. In fact, apparently, even the movie "Chham Chhama Chham" (the album listing) has a song that goes on similar lines.

Is this a case of the same song being released with subtle variations in 2 albums?

[sangeetbhakt]

CM2,

Can you reconcile your upload above with the following upload from "Dilli Ka Thug" by BJ in his thread "Pakka Dhaaga".

http://www.hamaraforums.com/index.php?show...indpost&p=80934

Upon listening, they seem to be the same song.

If you notice the starting chal re ameeran in both the songs is quite different- after O bandariya the song sounds the same- but again in the end it is little bit different.

Both songs had Ravi as the music director.

mine is surely from Bombay Ka chor.

Maybe SB could shed some light.

What's interesting is that the lyricists of these songs are different. Now remember that "Chal ri amiran...chal re fakire" is a general expression used in some other dialougues/songs too. In fact, apparently, even the movie "Chham Chhama Chham" (the album listing) has a song that goes on similar lines.

Is this a case of the same song being released with subtle variations in 2 albums?

I had heard the song in both films and somehow had not reconciled it in my
head. Seems like this song was sung twice, once for each film. The films have
a lot in common. Both were produced by S D Narang with New Oriental Pictures.
Both films star Kishore Kumar with music by Ravi. I have seen both films but
cannot recall the picturization. Probably worth a visit to my local store to get
them again. "Bombay ka chor" starred Mala Sinha with KK while "Dilli ka Thug"
had Nutan. From listening to the songs, it seems like the songs were recorded
at different times for the films.
The interesting thing is that all songs in "Bombay ka chor" are attributed to
Rajendar Krishan. HOwever, the songs in "Dilli ka Thug" are penned by S H BIhari,
Shailendra and Majrooh (the Geetkosh is not specific about which song was
written by which lyricist). So that is a bit of an anomaly.

All of the above is just data from the GK. I don't really know the deal on this.
Strange.