![]() |
![]() |
cinemaniac2 |
![]()
Post
#1
|
![]() Dedicated Member ![]() Group: Away Posts: 2796 Joined: 12-November 03 Member No.: 107 ![]() |
Film-Aakhri Dao-1958
Madan Mohan-Majrooh *Shekhar & Nutan Hai Unki Woh Nigahen |
![]() ![]() |
Priya |
![]()
Post
#2
|
![]() Dedicated Member ![]() Group: Away Posts: 14700 Joined: 24-October 03 From: Kerala, India Member No.: 25 ![]() |
Well I am all at sea!!! What do our authorities--the Mule and SB say?
![]() ![]() Do not sound like Asha to me anyway but nice snippets and so thanks Cineji!!!!! ![]() |
sangeetbhakt |
![]()
Post
#3
|
Dedicated Member ![]() Group: Members Posts: 2090 Joined: 19-November 04 Member No.: 1288 ![]() |
QUOTE(priya @ Feb 27 2005, 11:33 AM) Well I am all at sea!!! What do our authorities--the Mule and SB say? ![]() offence meant at the tagging together--no offence to either one of U ![]() Koi baat nahi. I am quite honored to be compared the all-knowing HF mule. The laath maarna part of the mule shall be conveniently ignored. QUOTE Do not sound like Asha to me anyway but nice snippets and so thanks Cineji!!!!! I agree that neither song sounds like Asha. Aur Suraiaya bhi nahi lagte. There was (is???) a Hindustani classical singer called Nirmala Devi who was known for her rendition of thumris. She is in fact the mother of actor Govinda. The voice sounds like hers. I have not heard her much so standard disclaimers apply. I compared the voice in these couplets with that of the voice in the song "Ulfat ke jaam pila pila mere saaqi" from the same film sung by Nirmala Devi. And it seems to be a match. Nirmala Devi is also one of the voices in the song from "Bawarchi" by Madan Mohan "Bhor bhayi aaya andhiyaara". So, this COULD be the "Nirmala" who has sung one of the other songs in this film and could also be voice of this unknown woman. End of my thesis ![]() |
mohd2004 |
![]()
Post
#4
|
Dedicated Member ![]() Group: Banned Posts: 2626 Joined: 21-April 04 Member No.: 419 ![]() |
QUOTE(sangeetbhakt @ Feb 28 2005, 04:23 AM) QUOTE(priya @ Feb 27 2005, 11:33 AM) Well I am all at sea!!! What do our authorities--the Mule and SB say? ![]() offence meant at the tagging together--no offence to either one of U ![]() Koi baat nahi. I am quite honored to be compared the all-knowing HF mule. The laath maarna part of the mule shall be conveniently ignored. QUOTE Do not sound like Asha to me anyway but nice snippets and so thanks Cineji!!!!! I agree that neither song sounds like Asha. Aur Suraiaya bhi nahi lagte. There was (is???) a Hindustani classical singer called Nirmala Devi who was known for her rendition of thumris. She is in fact the mother of actor Govinda. The voice sounds like hers. I have not heard her much so standard disclaimers apply. I compared the voice in these couplets with that of the voice in the song "Ulfat ke jaam pila pila mere saaqi" from the same film sung by Nirmala Devi. And it seems to be a match. Nirmala Devi is also one of the voices in the song from "Bawarchi" by Madan Mohan "Bhor bhayi aaya andhiyaara". So, this COULD be the "Nirmala" who has sung one of the other songs in this film and could also be voice of this unknown woman. End of my thesis ![]() Absolutely right Sangeetbhakt-ji, this is indeed Nirmala Devi, classical singer, mother of actor/Hero, Govinda. Mohd. |
![]() ![]() |
![]() |
Lo-Fi Version | Disclaimer | HF Guidelines | ![]() |
Time is now: 19th June 2025 - 12:18 PM |