Do You Know Any Pair Of Almost Identically Tuned Songs Of Rafi Saab?, I Now Know Not Eleven, But Twlve Pairs! Options

[venkat]

Friends,

It was only after I joined HF that I came to know this. There are at least twelve pairs of Rafi Saab's songs which are almost identical in tune.

PAIR-I:

1. "Ek Chameli Ki Mandwe Tale"--Film: Cha Cha Cha(1964)---MD:Iqbal Quereshi--Rafi and Asha

2. "Aaj Mausam Ki Masti Mein Gaaye Pawan"--Film:Banarasi Thug(1962)---MD:Iqbal Quereshi---Rafi and Lata


PAIR-II:

1. "Tu Hind Bane Ya na Musalmaan Banega, Insaan Ki Aulad"---Film:Dhool Ka Phool(1959)---MD:N.Datta---Rafi

2. "Kya Kya Na Sitam Tujh Pe Huve Mehlon Ki Raani"---Film:Mohini(1957)---MD:N.Datta---Rafi


Incidentally, within each of these Pairs, the MDs are the same!

Firends, please let me know if you know any other such almost identical pairs. Mind you, only almost identical pairs. Not similar pairs, of which there are plenty!

Venkat

P.S. Another seven or eight pairs have been discovered in the following posts!

This post has been edited by venkat: Sep 14 2010, 06:25 PM

[Dr_Faustus]

Two songs with the same tune:

1. TYPE: Film: Deedar
Song: Hue hum jin ke liye barbaad
Time: 4.11 min
Bitrate: 160 kbps




2. TYPE: Naat LIVE VERSION
Song: Basi hai dil main Nabi ki yaad
Time: 5.06 min
Bitrate: 128 kbps




Songs courtesy HF!!

Enjoy!

Faust

[nadeem mohd]

Two songs with the same tune:

1. TYPE: Film: Deedar
Song: Hue hum jin ke liye barbaad
Time: 4.11 min
Bitrate: 160 kbps




2. TYPE: Naat LIVE VERSION
Song: Basi hai dil main Nabi ki yaad
Time: 5.06 min
Bitrate: 128 kbps




Songs courtesy HF!!

Enjoy!

Faust

Thanks a lot for this pair of songs dr ji

[/ShaaNAwaaz\]

here some new one .,,,


1) CHAA GAYE BAADAL NEEL GAGAN PAR - GHUL GAYA KAJRA SHAAM DHALE .. ...filmi



1) PAAGAL CHANDA MERE MAN KI AAG MEIN SAARI RAAT JALE . non- filmi

==============================
2) AAPSE MAINE MERI JAAN MUHABBAT KI HAI , AAP CHAE TO MERI ,,


2) SOCHTA HUN KE MAINE TUMHEIN ..... shahshi kaporr film.

==============================

3) RAHEIN NA RAHEIN HUM , BANKE HAWA,,,,,


3) YAHI HAI TAMANNA TERE GHAR KE SAAMNE,,


==============================

..there maybe more ,,

[venkat]

here some new one .,,,


1) CHAA GAYE BAADAL NEEL GAGAN PAR - GHUL GAYA KAJRA SHAAM DHALE .. ...filmi



1) PAAGAL CHANDA MERE MAN KI AAG MEIN SAARI RAAT JALE . non- filmi

==============================
2) AAPSE MAINE MERI JAAN MUHABBAT KI HAI , AAP CHAE TO MERI ,,


2) SOCHTA HUN KE MAINE TUMHEIN ..... shahshi kaporr film.

==============================

3) RAHEIN NA RAHEIN HUM , BANKE HAWA,,,,,


3) YAHI HAI TAMANNA TERE GHAR KE SAAMNE,,


==============================

..there maybe more ,,

Shanawaz Ji, thanks for the post. But, what we are looking for are not just distinct similarities in flavor or feel, nor even idenicality only in Mukhda. To qualify, both the songs should be almost identical in tune both on Mukhda and the Antaras. The six pairs we have now do meet these criteria.

Do tell us if you have a pair that strictly complies with these criteria. I know your 2 and 3 pairs do not qualify. But, in your first pair, I know the Film song well, but not the Non-filmi song. If you feel these two are almost identical in tune in Mukhda and also Antara, please u/l both the songs.

Thanks.

Venkat

Venkat

[desai2rn]

here some new one .,,,


1) CHAA GAYE BAADAL NEEL GAGAN PAR - GHUL GAYA KAJRA SHAAM DHALE .. ...filmi



1) PAAGAL CHANDA MERE MAN KI AAG MEIN SAARI RAAT JALE . non- filmi

==============================
2) AAPSE MAINE MERI JAAN MUHABBAT KI HAI , AAP CHAE TO MERI ,,


2) SOCHTA HUN KE MAINE TUMHEIN ..... shahshi kaporr film.

==============================

3) RAHEIN NA RAHEIN HUM , BANKE HAWA,,,,,


3) YAHI HAI TAMANNA TERE GHAR KE SAAMNE,,


==============================

..there maybe more ,,

Shanawaz Ji, thanks for the post. But, what we are looking for are not just distinct similarities in flavor or feel, nor even idenicality only in Mukhda. To qualify, both the songs should be almost identical in tune both on Mukhda and the Antaras. The six pairs we have now do meet these criteria.

Do tell us if you have a pair that strictly complies with these criteria. I know your 2 and 3 pairs do not qualify. But, in your first pair, I know the Film song well, but not the Non-filmi song. If you feel these two are almost identical in tune in Mukhda and also Antara, please u/l both the songs.

Thanks.

Venkat

Venkat

Venkatji, Pagal Chanda.... in my opinion is Rafi saab's one of the best if ' not the best ' non filmi song.
Just a little surprised, being a huge Rafi fan, you have not heard it before, . Here it is. I have not
heard the other one.

[Binod]

Pagal Chanda.... in my opinion is Rafi saab's one of the best if ' not the best ' non filmi song.

Thanks Ramesh Ji.

Binod.